JOSH NEWMASTER

Reflections

When Faith Feels Like One More Thing to Get Right

By Josh Newmaster · October 15, 2026 · 5 minute read

For many people, faith begins as something that feels like home. Somewhere along the way, it can quietly turn into a checklist: read more, pray better, serve more, doubt less. And when you fall short of the list, faith stops feeling like rest and starts feeling like one more place you are failing.

If that is where you are, you are not alone. Noticing it is not a sign that something is wrong with you. It is often the place where something new begins.

How faith becomes a performance

Most of us did not choose this. We learned it. Many of us were praised for being responsible, helpful, and dependable, and over time those qualities became the way we earned our place. It makes sense that we would bring the same habits into our relationship with God: earning, proving, and keeping score.

Years in ministry showed me how easily this happens, even to people who love God deeply. A few signs it may be happening to you:

  • You feel more guilt than peace when you think about God.
  • Rest feels like something you have to earn first.
  • You measure your spiritual life by how much you produce.
  • Honest questions or doubts feel dangerous to say out loud.

What if you started from love instead?

Jesus spent a great deal of time with people who could not get it right. His invitation was rarely "try harder." Far more often it was "come." At the heart of the Christian story is a simple order: love comes first. We do not climb our way toward it. We respond to it.

The rhythm I keep returning to is Receive, Reflect, Radiate:

  • Receive. Let in the love already reaching you, before you do anything to deserve it.
  • Reflect. Notice the fears and old stories that turned faith into a test.
  • Radiate. Let what you receive shape how you treat people, freely and without keeping score.

A small practice for this week

  1. Sit for two minutes and set the list down. No reading plan, no prayer goals.
  2. Pray one honest sentence, even if it is "I am tired of trying so hard."
  3. Notice what you feel when you stop performing, and stay with it for a moment.

A practice does not need to be impressive to be real. Small and honest is enough.

You do not have to do this alone

We cannot see our own blind spots, and the patterns that turn faith into performance are hard to notice from the inside. Sometimes what helps most is a trusted person to be honest with. If you would like that kind of space, I would be glad to hear from you.

Want a next step?

Take the free Lantern Assessment to see where to start, or reach out about 1 on 1 coaching.